The shape of individual differences in judgment: shared axes, personal weights, and when their spread crosses the consensus

the-shape-of-individual-differences-in-judgment:-shared-axes,-personal-weights,-and-when-their-spread-crosses-the-consensus

The shape of individual differences in judgment: shared axes, personal weights, and when their spread crosses the consensus

[Submitted on 17 Nov 2026]

View PDF HTML (experimental)

Abstract:People differ in how they judge faces, artworks, photographs and jokes. Previous work measured the size of these differences; we ask what shape they take. We wrote three candidate shapes as nested generative models (same-sign reweighting of shared dimensions, a linear transform that allows reversal, and stimulus-specific offsets) and compared how well they predict people unseen in training, using ten public datasets (about 20,000 raters). The models recovered a person’s judgment space from 10-20 judgments and predicted judgments of unseen stimuli. For faces, reweighting was sufficient, and weights opposing the population were not statistically detected. For artworks, weights spread continuously along the shared abstract-figurative direction, and 28 percent of raters fell on the opposite side from the population. This tail was much smaller when a different rater sample judged the same artworks. Individual differences thus differ in shape as well as size, and the shape depends on domain and raters.

Submission history

From: Hiroshi Higashi [view email]
[v1] Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:12:19 UTC (664 KB)